1991-1992: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Ryan Richard |
Men's Soccer |
All-Conference Team |
| Alan Nelson |
Men's Soccer |
All-Conference Team |
| Doug Harden |
Men's Soccer |
All-Conference Team |
| Suzanne Kappel |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Greg Hochman |
Men's Tennis |
All-Conference Team |
| Dave Lombardi |
Men's Tennis |
All-Conference Team |
| Bryan Mahoney |
Men's Tennis |
All-Conference Team |
| Teresa Thomson | Women's Tennis | All-Conference #1 Singles Champion |
| Bobbie Wilhour | Women's Tennis | All-Conference #3 Singles Champion |
| Jennifer Narramore | Women's Tennis | All-Conference #2 Doubles Champion |
| Bobbie Wilhour | Women's Tennis | All-Conference #2 Doubles Champion |
| Fred Dorsey |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Chris Jemo |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Chris Jemo |
Men's Basketball |
NJCAA Pre-Season All-American Team |
| Rob Dimino | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
1992-1993: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Alan Nelson |
Men's Soccer |
All-Conference Team |
| Kelly McKeon |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Jennifer Narrimore | Tennis | All-Conference Doubles Champion |
| Sharon Matisak | Tennis | All-Conference Doubles Champion |
| Shirley Jackson | Tennis | All-Conference #2 Singles Champion |
| Tom Edwards |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Brian Peck | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Michelle Capparell |
Softball |
All-Conference Team |
1993-1994: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Ryan Schlagheck | Men's Soccer | All Conference Team |
| Beth Reibeling |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Sheri Rundle |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Sue Francis |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Gina Mattern | Tennis | All-Conference #2 Singles Champion |
| Louis Pacelli | Tennis | All-Conference #1 Doubles Champion |
| Ryan Sugarman | Tennis | All-Conference #1 Doubles Champion |
| Tom Edwards |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Jason Bodnar |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Jason Molli | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Mike Behr | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Colleen McNicholas |
Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Heidi Rittenhouse |
Softball |
All-Conference Team |
1994-1995: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Brian Bushwood | Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Neil McGillis |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Angela Brewer |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Sue Francis |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Jenn Pedora |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Sean Loughlin | Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| James Smith | Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Beth Squier | Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Ed Opella |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Paul Reilly |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Stacey Surovec |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Mike Behr |
Baseball |
All-Conference Team |
| John Harmonosky | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Shawn Shank | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
1995-1996: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Jeremy Edmonds |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Brian Mastervich |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Brian Rutecki |
Men's Soccer |
All-Conference Team |
| Amy Brenfleck |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Kristina Lipps |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Jill McKiernan |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Jenn Padora |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Richard Hagel |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| James Smith |
Tennis |
All-Conference Team |
| James Smith |
Tennis |
All-Conference #1 Singles Champion |
| Duane Dudeck |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Turhan Wilbon |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Parisa Farhi |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Christina Robbins |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| William Burkholder | Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Justin Dietterick | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Edgar Upson | Baseball | All-Conference Team |