2006-2007: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Tim Shelton |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Joe Albanese |
Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Alex Aromstrong |
Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Brandon Farzad |
Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Chris Lee |
Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Naiz Osman |
Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Elise Williams |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Kae Cobb |
Women's Volleyball | All-American Scholar |
| Karen Helfrich |
Women's Volleyball |
All-American Scholar |
| Rachel Piccione |
Women's Volleyball | All-American Scholar |
| Tramone Clark |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Brett Edride |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Keiser Zamora |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Bob Colaneri |
Men's Basketball | All-American Scholar |
| Anthony Spaulding |
Men's Basketball | All-American Scholar |
| Shannon Byers |
Women's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Ashley Kessell |
Women's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Rachel Selert |
Women's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Mike Graaf |
Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Michael Lennon |
Tennis | All-American Scholar |
| Samantha Nicholson |
Tennis | All-American Scholar |
| Luke Koval |
Tennis | All-American Scholar |
| Jessica Hearing |
Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Tiffany Reinhart |
Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Megan Robbins |
Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Lindsey Ludorf |
Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Brittany Farrell | Softball | All-American Scholar |
| Tiffany Reinhart |
Softball | All-American Scholar |
| Danielle Rufo |
Softball | All-American Scholar |
2007-2008: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Bryan Caicedo |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Colin Cope |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Joseph Albanese |
Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Christopher Horton |
Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Thomas Russell |
Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Joseph Sekula |
Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Karen Helfrich |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Elise Williams |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Athena Abate |
Women's Volleyball | All-American Scholar |
| Rachel Piccione |
Women's Volleyball |
All-American Scholar |
| Yovanny Ramierz |
Women's Volleyball | All-American Scholar |
| Sara Skekel | Women's Volleyball | All-American Scholar |
| Tramone Clark | Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| James Harley | Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Keiser Zamora | Men's Basketball | All-American Scholar |
| Stephanie Halliday | Women's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Amanda Pursell |
Women's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Melissa Porth |
Women's Basketball | All-American Scholar |
| Rachel Riley | Women's Basketball | All-American Scholar |
| Jeff Houser |
Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Bob Calderone |
Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Christopher Cascio |
Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Caleb Day |
Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Albert DeSanto |
Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Robert Hines |
Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Jeffrey Houser |
Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Sean Landis |
Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Michael McGlynn |
Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Arthur Luchowski |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Melissa Froehlich |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| William Christensen |
Tennis | All-American Scholar |
| Arthur Luchowski |
Tennis | All-American Scholar |
| Jason Prince |
Tennis | All-American Scholar |
| Megan Robbins |
Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Ashley Donnelly |
Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Megan Notaro |
Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Amanda Purcel |
Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Dayna Williams | Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Ashley Donnelly |
Softball | All-American Scholar |
| Meghan Parkhurst |
Softball | All-American Scholar |
2008-2009: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Joseph Sekula |
Men's Soccer | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Josh Bloom |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Colin Cope | Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Yovanny Ramirez |
Women's Volleyball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Amelia Buccarelli |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Finesse Hempfing |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Brett Ednie |
Men's Basketball | USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| Keiser Zamora |
Men's Basketball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Tramone Clark |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Brett Ednie |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| J.J. Reinmiller |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Katie Beach |
Women's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Amanda Pursel |
Women's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| John Coleman |
Tennis | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Arthur Luchowski |
Tennis | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Jason Prince |
Tennis | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Dirk Behney |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Arthur Luchowski |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Jennifer Edsall | Softball | USCAA All-American 1st Team |
| Alyssa Rodzewich |
Softball |
USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| Kayleigh Crockenberg |
Softball | USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| Brittany Kringer |
Softball | USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| Ashley Donnelly |
Softball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Ariana Hydro | Softball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Kayleigh Crockenberg | Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Jennifer Edsall | Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Brittany Kringer | Softball | All-Conference Team |
2009-2010: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Alex Morse |
Men's Soccer | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Thomas Douger |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Mike Malfitano |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Jason Machamer |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Keiser Zamora | Men's Basketball |
USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| Keiser Zamora | Men's Basketball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Brandon Boekel |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Keiser Zamora |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Kyle Septer |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Marty Mrozinski |
Softball |
PSUAC Coach of the Year |
| Jenn Edsal |
Softball | PSUAC Pitcher of the Year |
| Jenn Edsal | Softball | PSUAC Player of the Year (tie) |
| Kayleigh Crockenberg |
Softball | PSUAC Player of the Year (tie) |
| Kayleigh Crockenberg |
Softball | USCAA All-American 1st Team |
| Jenn Edsal |
Softball | USCAA All-American 1st Team |
| Brittany Kringer |
Softball | USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| Katie Rearick |
Softball | USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| Alyssa Rodzewich |
Softball | USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| Ashley Donnelly |
Softball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Ariana Hydro |
Softball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Alyssa Rodzewich | Softball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Kayleigh Crockenberg | Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Jenn Edsal | Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Heather Griffiths | Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Brittany Kringer | Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Katie Rearick | Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Alyssa Rodzewich | Softball | All-Conference Team |
2010-2011: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Corey Breznak |
Men's Soccer |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Gary Marmo |
Men's Soccer | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Michael Hernandez |
Men's Soccer | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Kyle Bloom |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Zane Kelsey |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| R.J. Pita |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Landen Ward |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Ashley Perez |
Women's Volleyball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Marsha-Lee Wright |
Women's Volleyball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Ashly Perez |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Kyle Septor |
Tennis |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Kristina Zwolenik |
Tennis |
All-Conference Team |
| Brandon Boekel |
Men's Basketball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Eric Radishofski |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Alyssa Meyers |
Women's Basketball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Partice Lombard |
Women's Basketball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Amanda Collins |
Women's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Tiffany Donnelly |
Women's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Krystin Baker | Softball | USCAA All-American 1st Team |
| Alyssa Rodzewich | Softball | USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| Krystin Baker |
Softball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Ariel Kravetsky |
Softball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Emily Roat |
Softball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Alyssa Rodzewich |
Softball | USCAA National All-Academic |