1996-1997 through 2000-2001 seasons
1996-1997: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Mike Sherman |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Brian Hall |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Amy Brenfleck |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Shana Erdman |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Abbie Lezak |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Jill McKiernan |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Angela Gillham |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Richard Hagel | Tennis |
All-Conference Team |
| Cheryl Smith |
Tennis |
All-Conference Team |
| Andrew Schreffler |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Mike Petrucci |
Baseball | All-Conference Team |
1997-1998: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Aaron Craige |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Chad Ficocelli |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Ronald Smith | Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Matthew Thompson | Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Shana Erdman |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Abbie Lezak |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Melanie Patton |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Keith Stancavage |
Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Chad McCormick |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Ovidio Alfano |
Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Christopher Carter |
Baseball | All-Conference Team |
1998-1999: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Daniel Ryan |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Melanie Patton |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Jennifer Shoemaker |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Jeffrey Rush |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Tyler Longenecker |
Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Jennifer Howland | Softball | Academic All-Americans |
| Ryan Novak | Softball | Academic All-Americans |
| Debbie Kupsho | Softball | Academic All-Americans |
1999-2000: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Scott Brecht |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Shaun Flook |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| James Hearne |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Don Shiner |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Melody Cressman |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Jaime Petruska |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Alison Stern |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Wendy Witcoski |
Women's Volleyball |
All-Conference Team |
| Ingrid Barnes |
Women's Volleyball | Academic All-American |
| Kevin Kolodgie | Tennis | Academic All-American |
| Kevin Kolodgie | Tennis | All-Conference #1 Singles Champion |
| Kevin Kolodgie | Tennis | All-Conference #1 Doubles Champion |
| Matt Bouis |
Tennis | All-Conference #1 Doubles Champion |
| Alan Chang |
Tennis | All-Conference #2 Doubles Champion |
| George Sampson |
Tennis | All-Conference #2 Doubles Champion |
| Tiffany Callaio | Tennis | All-Conference #1 Singles Champion |
| Karen Stolp | Tennis | All-Conference #2 Singles Champion |
| Tiffany Callaio | Tennis | All-Conference #1 Doubles Champion |
| Karen Stolp | Tennis | All-Conference #1 Doubles Champion |
| Kyle Minnick |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference First Team |
| Julius Perry |
Men's Basketball |
All-Conference First Team |
| Joe Huxta | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Bryan Kessell | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Jennifer Howland | Softball | Academic All-American |
| Jaime Petruska | Softball | Academic All-American |
| Jamie Tarone | Softball | Academic All-American |
| Debbie Kupsho | Softball | Academic All-American |
2000-2001: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Mike Baclawski | Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Daniel Field |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Nathan Hokenbrough |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Jon Kokinda |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Bryan Rhoads |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Bryan Rhoads | Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Brian Ferentz | Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Daniel Field | Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Jonas Stawski | Men's Soccer | All-American Scholar |
| Joanne Lesh | Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Sara Grabowski |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Molly Ehrhardt |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Melinda Reed |
Women's Volleyball |
All-American Scholar |
| Patricia Rowe | Women's Volleyball | All-American Scholar |
| Jeremy Haddock | Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Matthew Tucker | Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Brad Yuricheck | Men's Basketball |
All-Conference Team |
| Owen Christman | Men's Basketball | All-American Scholar |
| Daniel Field | Men's Basketball | All-American Scholar |
| Matthew Tucker | Men's Basketball | All-American Scholar |
| Bryan Kessell | Baseball | PCAA All-State Selection |
| Bryan Kessell | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Matthew Furedi | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Brad Yuricheck | Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| James Amato | Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Christopher Cascio | Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Bryan Kessell | Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Jeffery Koch | Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Matthew Furedi | Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Robert Oltra | Baseball | All-American Scholar |
| Tiffany Callaio | Tennis | All-Conference #1 Singles Champion |
| Tiffany Callaio | Tennis | All-Conference Doubles Champion |
| Valerie Sturiale | Tennis | All-Conference Doubles Champion |
| Heather Bensinger |
Softball | All Conference Team |
| Jessica Fischer |
Softball | All Conference Team |
| Jessica May |
Softball | All Conference Team |
| Kristin Miller |
Softball | All Conference Team |
| Jessica May |
Softball | All-American Scholar |
| Jamie Tarone | Softball | All-American Scholar |