2011-2012 through 2015-2016 seasons
2011-2012: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Steven Schwartz |
Men's Soccer | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Seth Zerby |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Jonathan Mazzella |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Mike Slodysko |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Tony Slusser |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Elizabeth Strong |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Ashly Perez |
Women's Volleyball | All-American Scholar |
| Kristina Zwolenik | Tennis | PSUAC Female Player of the Year |
| Kristina Zwolenik | Tennis | All-Conference #1 Singles Champion |
| Alexandria Scudder | Tennis | All-Conference #2 Singles Champion |
| Kristina Zwolenik | Tennis | All-Conference #1 Doubles Champion |
| Alexandria Scudder | Tennis | All-Conference #1 Doubles Champion |
| Thomas Fausnaught | Tennis | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Alexandria Scudder | Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Kristina Zwolenik | Tennis | All-Conference Team |
| Nicholas Tristani | Golf | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Patrick Blaney | Golf | All-Conference Team |
| Taylor Kreischer | Golf | All-Conference Team |
| Nicholas Tristani | Golf | All-Conference Team |
| Casey Petty |
Men's Basketball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Michael Serra |
Men's Basketball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Eric Radishofski |
Men's Basketball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Michael Taylor |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Alyssa Meyers |
Women's Basketball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Chelsea Shervinskie |
Women's Basketball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Taylor Cannon |
Women's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Tiffany Donnelly |
Women's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Ryan Campbell |
Baseball | USCAA National-All Academic |
| Krystin Baker |
Softball |
USCAA National-All Academic |
| Alyssa Rodzewich | Softball | USCAA National-All Academic |
| Brooke Hess | Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Emily Roat |
Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Sabrina Babula | Softball | All-Conference Team |
| Alyssa Rodzewich | Softball | All-Conference Team |
2012-2013: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Kyle Venditti | Men's Soccer | PSUAC Freshman of the Year |
| Chris Hummel |
Men's Soccer | USCAA All-American 2nd Team |
| Kyle Venditti |
Men's Soccer | USCAA All-American 2nd Team |
| Jahsi Weste |
Men's Soccer | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Dylan Metz |
Men's Soccer | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Kyle Venditti | Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Michael Slodysko |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Chris Hummel |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Justin Eckert |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Team |
| Elysha Bolschi |
Women's Volleyball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Natalia Klecha |
Women's Volleyball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Ashly Perez |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Team |
| Casey Petty |
Men's Basketball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Ashkan Naderi |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Dwayne Vines |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Alexis Daly |
Women's Basketball |
USCAA All-American First Team |
| Taylor Cannon |
Women's Basketball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Brittany Sharpe |
Women's Basketball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Chelsea Shervinskie |
Women's Basketball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Alexis Daly |
Women's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Taylor Cannon |
Women's Basketball | All-Conference Team |
| Tariq Alnuaimi |
Tennis |
All-Conference Team |
| Lawrence Santa Maria |
Baseball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Kyle Schwartz |
Baseball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Sanil Shah |
Baseball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Jake Bostick |
Baseball | All-Conference Team |
| Robert Shustack |
Baseball | All-Conference Team |
2013-2014: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
2014-2015: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
2015-2016: |
| Name |
Sport | Award |
| Kyle Venditti |
Men's Soccer | USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| James Fisher |
Men's Soccer | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Michael Principe |
Men's Soccer | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Arielle Zahodnick |
Men's Soccer | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Steven Principe |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference First Team |
| Kyle Venditti | Men's Soccer | All-Conference First Team |
| James Fisher |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Second Team |
| Tyler Wyllie |
Men's Soccer | All-Conference Second Team |
| Katie Behnert | Golf | USCAA Women's Golf National Champion |
| Katie Behnert | Golf | USCAA All-American |
| Garrett Madison | Golf | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Ty Morzilla | Golf | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Garrett Madison | Golf | All-Conference Team |
| Ty Morzilla | Golf | All-Conference Team |
| Jessenia Wright |
Women's Volleyball | USCAA National All-Academic |
| Tina Beiland |
Women's Volleyball | All-Conference Honorable Mention |
| Jordan Singletary |
Men's Basketball | USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| Jordan Singletary |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference Second Team |
| Royce Brathwaite |
Men's Basketball | All-Conference Honorable Mention |
| Alexis Daly |
Women's Basketball |
USCAA Player of the Year |
| Alexis Daly |
Women's Basketball | USCAA All-American First Team |
| McKenzie Prutsman |
Women's Basketball | USCAA All-American Honorable Mention |
| Alexis Daly |
Women's Basketball | PSUAC Player of the Year |
| McKenzie Prutsman |
Women's Basketball | PSUAC Newcomer of the Year |
| Paul Appel |
Women's Basketball | PSUAC Coach of the Year |
| Alexis Daly |
Women's Basketball | All-Conference First Team |
| McKenzie Prutsman |
Women's Basketball | All-Conference Honorable Mention |
| Kayla Rhome |
Softball |
USCAA National All-Academic |
| Sara Stauffer |
Softball | USCAA National All-Academic |